When planning a kitchen upgrade, one of the biggest decisions is whether to go for custom kitchen cabinets or cabinet refacing. Both can transform your space—but which one gives you the best value for your money?
Let’s break it down and explore what’s actually worth your investment.
What’s the Difference?
Before diving into costs, it helps to understand what each option involves:
- Custom kitchen cabinets: New cabinets made from scratch to fit your kitchen. You pick the size, shape, layout, finishes, and hardware.
- Cabinet refacing: Keeps your cabinet boxes but replaces doors, drawer fronts, and exterior panels. It gives your cabinets a fresh look without changing the layout.
Is Cabinet Refacing Cheaper Than Custom Kitchen Cabinets?
In most cases, yes. Cabinet refacing costs about 30% to 50% less than a full custom kitchen cabinet installation. Here’s a general cost comparison:
- Cabinet refacing cost estimate: $7,000–$12,000 for an average kitchen
- Custom kitchen cabinet pricing: $15,000–$30,000 or more, depending on materials, layout, and size
Refacing is quicker and involves less labor. You can usually finish the project in a few days, while new cabinet installation may take weeks.
Pros and Cons of Each Option
Custom Kitchen Cabinets:
✅ Pros
- Full design freedom
- Maximizes storage and functionality
- Adds the most value in high-end homes
❌ Cons
- Higher cost
- Longer installation time
Cabinet Refacing:
✅ Pros
- More affordable
- Less mess and downtime
- Keeps existing cabinet layout
❌ Cons
- No layout changes
- Can’t fix cabinet damage or poor design
Remodel ROI Breakdown
If you’re upgrading your kitchen to boost resale value, both options offer good returns—but custom kitchen cabinets often win long-term.
“Custom cabinets not only improve how your kitchen looks, but how it works,” says Eugene Bershadsky, Senior Designer at Impressions Kitchens. “If your layout doesn’t meet your needs, refacing won’t fix the problem. Custom cabinetry does.”
That said, if your layout works fine and your cabinet boxes are in great shape, refacing is a smart, low-cost kitchen upgrade option.
What Saves You More in the Long Run?
Think beyond the upfront price. Here are questions to help you decide:
- Do you like your current cabinet layout?
→ Refacing might be enough. - Do you need more storage or new configurations?
→ Custom cabinets are the better fit. - Are your cabinets damaged or outdated inside?
→ Refacing won’t solve internal issues. Go custom. - Are you staying in your home long-term?
→ Invest in custom cabinets for better function and quality.
Affordable Kitchen Remodel Tips
If you’re working with a tighter budget but still want a fresh look:
- Combine custom cabinets for base units with refacing for uppers
- Opt for stock materials in custom builds
- Ask about custom cabinet installation deals in your area
- Compare multiple quotes for the best value
“Always work with a kitchen cabinet contractor near you who can walk you through both options and offer a clear breakdown,” says Eugene. “We often build quotes for both, so clients can compare side by side.”
So… Which Option Pays Off?
If you’re flipping a property or need a quick update, refacing wins on affordability.
If you’re planning your dream kitchen or need more storage and function, custom cabinets offer a better ROI.
Whichever route you choose, make sure to compare kitchen cabinet quotes, get clear timelines, and review the warranty options.
Ready to explore your kitchen upgrade options?
Book a free kitchen remodel consultation with Impressions Kitchens today. We’ll help you decide between refacing vs. new cabinets cost, layout changes, and finishes that fit your space and your budget. Serving Toronto, Mississauga, Oakville, and Vaughan, our expert team is here to bring your dream kitchen to life.
More Information:
